Home › Forums › Decoding His Signals / How Does He Feel About Me? › He didn’t say I love you back
- This topic has 4 replies and was last updated 4 years, 11 months ago by Asayi.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Alicia
I have never tried to say “I love you” to someone as the first to say it. Now I have, and he didn’t say it back. Now I just feel so weird. In my rational mind, I’m thinking it’s perfectly fine that he is not there yet, but I just feel so vulnerable and in some way that I have more feelings than him?
He is a very expressive person. He tells me how much I mean to him, how much he is in love with me, that he “locked me” to be his forever, we got rings with each other’s names inside, he even got a necklace made with our initials and the infinity sign as a symbol of us being together forever. He treats me like a princess, I actually feel loved by him.
We have only dated for 5 months, so everything is moving rather fast. At least compared to what I’m used to.
Of course I wasn’t sure that he would say “I love you” back when I said it, but I have to admit I kinda thought he would. Several times he actually said it, but it was more in that way like: adore you, and like you so much kinda spontaneous “I love you”, if that makes sense. Sometimes I just smiled when he said it, other times I told him, don’t say that until you really mean it. I also told him one time, do you mean you love me or you are in love with me. And he meant in love of course, this was after knowing each other for like 2 months.
So anyway, yesterday we had a really romantic moment where we were telling each other how much we mean to each other, that we want a future together and so on. Then there was a time in that conversation where it just felt right to tell him I love him. Even though it is so fast, I really feel like I do love him. So I said it. He got the biggest smile on his face, it made him so happy to hear it. He told me to say it again which I did and he was so excited, I think he even had some tears in his eyes. Then after a few minutes of just smiling, hugging and so on, he didn’t say it back. Then I started to get a really weird feeling inside, I guess like a feeling of rejection?
Then I started crying, and he took me in his hug, he asked me if it was because he didn’t say it back and I told him yes. He told me straight up, I am so in love with you and you mean so much to me, I don’t love you yet, and who knows when it happens. Maybe after a year, maybe five, but I will tell you when I do. And he said, don’t feel bad that you said it, someone has to say it first.
I think he handled the situation in such a good way, but I keep thinking about it now. Like I shouldn’t have said it. And like: so I’m with someone that I love and he doesn’t love me? What to do now? I feel like I exposed my feelings, and there are no taking them back, and I feel so weird about it. Any thoughts or advice?
SsWell thats all bit confusing because I’d say that being *in love* with some one is more serious than saying I love you?
The things he has said all pointed to him loving you but then what he said after you said you love him is odd – it doesn’t make sense!
Sorry I can’t be much assistance here because I’m as confused as you are!
LaneI agree, this guy is all over the place and can understand why you feel the way you do after he said he’s *in love with you* but *doesn’t love you yet*—which one is it! I believe its his way of saying we haven’t been together long enough to know if the love I feel for you now will be how I feel six months from now so is being cautiously optimistic.
Technically the two of you are still in the ‘infatuation stage’ (look it up) which can FEEL like true love but its not the deeper kind of love that a man needs to begin planning a long-term future yet because those feelings could begin to wane so he doesn’t want to set himself or you up for failure in the event it happens.
This is the trickiest part of coupling up prior to year one because you are surging with ‘love hormone’s’ but as you get to know each better there could be traits, characteristics, things one say’s or does that could be a turn off and/or those love hormone’s begin to dissipate with time to the point either he or you falls out of love. I would just continue being who you are, and lay off the love words for now, step back and allow it to blossom (progress) naturally and organically.
However I WOULD NOT wait a year or more for a man to say them. If he can’t or is unable to freely express them by the sixth month I would pull waaay back and not be accessible for at least a week. Don’t tell why, just that you need some ‘me time’ to think for a bit and seriously take the time to think if this is really the man you could or want to potentially spend your life with. This will do one of two things. It will also give him the time (space) to FULLY FEEL what his life without you in it feels like and either compel him to want to be with you because he truly does love you and the thought of you not being in his life would be too painful. OR he can’t achieve the level of love he needs to progress it forward and say he loves you because he doesn’t miss you in the way a man needs to miss you to take it further.
Either way, never give your power over to a man to decide your fate, take the bull by the horns and if he can’t step up and begin the process of fully integrating you into his life, and him in yours, then its best step out before it gets harder to step out because he keeps promising to deliver but never fully delivers.
Liz LemonI agree with the others. He is being majorly confusing. I understand why you feel the way you do.
“He tells me how much I mean to him, how much he is in love with me, that he “locked me” to be his forever, we got rings with each other’s names inside, he even got a necklace made with our initials and the infinity sign as a symbol of us being together forever.”
–This seems like a bit much to me after only 5 months, sorry! He’s laying it on really thick. He’s bought rings with your names engraved inside and an infinity necklace as a symbol of being together forever, after 5 months? But won’t say I love you? Can I ask how old you two are?
I agree that for now you should just step back and see how things progress. You are still in the honeymoon period of the relationship so you are feeling infatuated. See what happens in the next few months. I would not say ILY again, for now, and lay off some of the lovey-dovey talk. I would focus on developing the relationship rather than sitting around talking about how much you love each other.
Just a suggestion: Have you two gone away for a trip together yet? That’s a good relationship milestone and traveling together gives you great insight into another person. If you have not done it, plan a trip (even just a weekend away together). Look for ways to deepen the relationship that don’t involve staring into each others eyes and talking about how you’ll be together forever :-)
Also, don’t feel bad for saying ILY first! Don’t feel weird about it. That was a brave and meaningful thing to do. You shouldn’t feel bad or embarrassed for it. I’m sorry he did not reciprocate, but from what you describe, you had every reason to feel it and say it to him. So be proud that you are capable of loving and capable of expressing it.
AsayiBeing vulnerable is paradoxically being strong. You said it because you mean it. It takes a lot of courage to do what you did. Be proud of yourself. I do understand that you wanted him to say it back, but it shouldn’t be the main purpose for saying it. Look at it this way: you said it because you meant it and because he matters to you and you wanted him to know. THAT should be your main purpose of saying these three words. Now of course it’s great if he says it back, but learn to be okay with the fact that he didn’t at the very moment you told him. There’s no rule about this topic. Obviously, he was super happy that you told him and felt every three words that you told him. You should’ve left it at that. What he said after you started crying made me super confused too. Usually, we hear people saying ‘I love you, but I’m not in love with you’ when they break up and not the other way around… Anyways. For now, let the relationship evolves and pull back a little. I suggest you not to tell him that you love him for a while. When he says it, you’ll know he truly means it and not just because he thinks that’s what you want to hear. Because of course, you want him to mean it. If some time passes by (like a month or two) and he doesn’t say it, then maybe you should ask yourself if you want to maintain a relationship where the person doesn’t love you and doesn’t know if she ever will.
-
AuthorPosts