Home › Forums › Dating and Sex Advice › He has a dying sibling, what do I do?
- This topic has 16 replies and was last updated 4 years, 3 months ago by Jane.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Becca
I started dating a guy in August, we have a great connection and get along really well. We are very similar in terms of background, families, etc. Now his sister is dying and needs a liver transplant but can’t get one. She went into the hospital last week. He has always felt responsible for his sister and talked about her often. He has been at home with his family for the past week or so, they live in another city an hour away from where we live, and he has tried to come back but his family and sister have needed him and he’s been too worried to leave. Yesterday he messaged me saying they can’t do anything for her and he’s very depressed and doesn’t want to talk to anyone. I am very upset but trying not to take it personally. I told him I am there for him and to let me know if I can do anything. Has anyone had any experience with something like this?
NewbieI dont understand how a dying sibling of someone you date becomes a question on a dating forum. At first i assumed you were the same person that posted a question about a sister of a date dying after the first date and were i also responded that i assumed he made it up.
But you are seeing this guy since august you say. He is grieving and depressed and yet youre inclined to take it personally? Thats kind of selfish dont you think.
I think he has not bonded with you and therefore cant reach to you when in pain. He is overwhelmed bu hurt and has to deal with that somehow. And you might feel you want to be there for him, you are not what he is looking for. Some has to do with youre not his partner (like that would take up to a year to feel that connected and most with hiw guys process grieve. They dont like to be in pain so they dont want to talk about it.
Now i dont know the status of your relationship and i assume you want to help the guy and not asking because you want to feel important to him. You can actually Google how to help guys who grieve. I did that when my man lost his dog. And we knew each other for over a Year but i still wasnt sure how to handle it. In the end it came down to me telling him to reach out when he felt ready. And after that he liked a distraction so we watched a movie he picked. And then he was ready to talk to me.PaigeHis sister is dying and all you can think about is yourself? And I thought I was selfish.
BeccaSo maybe people are misunderstanding because these responses are pretty aggressive and unhelpful for the most part, although the first response had some helpful tips. I am asking what can I do to help him, what should I avoid doing, etc.
PaigeYou said you “took it personal” which makes NO sense. His sister dying has nothing to do with you.
PaigeOr you’re “trying” not to take it personal and you’re upset about it. Upset about what, exactly?
BeccaWhen I said “trying not to take it personally” I literally meant that my first reaction was “damn he doesn’t want to rely on me, what does this mean for us” but then realized that I shouldn’t even be thinking about “us” and him not wanting to talk isn’t about us. I get that. So now I am trying to figure out what to do moving forward, it’s a very rough feeling caring a lot about someone and feeling unable to be proactive in helping them.
T from NYIf you started dating this man in August – at 6-8 weeks you should have only begun to care for him because at that point you barely know him, his character, don’t have a clue of his coping style, don’t know his full level of interest in you or his emotional availability in terms of wanting to be in a committed relationship – as actions in conjunction with words, over time, is the only way you can truly suss out a man’s true interest.
So I advise getting on with your wonderful life as if you never met him UNLESS-UNTIL he reaches out. If you’ve already alerted him that you’re there for him – I would not reach out again. No not even if a month goes by. Single men do what they want, when they want to, most of the time regardless of their stressors. If he wants to be in your life, if he has space for that, and is interested – you will know.
T from NYPS Healthy, high quality men do want mothering or massive amounts of support from a woman their dating in the beginning stages. They want attraction, fun, a soft place to land and be themselves. That is what allows them to later bond, then later, truly partner with a woman. It’s not your role to “help” him except to be a healthy potential partner. Give yourself permission to be happy. Being fretful or having a desire to fix is usually not attractive to men. It may seem counter-intuitive because a lot of women are nurturing. But a lot of men take value in handling their emotional biz by themselves. Give him that respect and it will make you more appealing if he chooses to come back in the future because he’ll appreciate you allowed him to do what he needs to do.
NewbieI understand why you see it as not helpful but T wrote it down cristal clear. You only know this guy for a blip and you are not an item from what i got. This means, and thats also prettty blunt that every family member and all his friends have bonded with him more than you did at this point. So you did all you could and mirror him. When it comes to the timeline, around 2.5 months, you should have an idea about his level of interest. And if its not clear its usually a not that much.
BeccaI guess I didn’t clarify that we already decided on exclusive dating. Also, he got me pregnant and we had to go through an abortion together. He was there for me.
NewbieAn abortion for a woman is very heavy even if she is sure about it. So im very sorry for you that you had to go through that. If you are confident your bond is strong enough already and he is all in (which to me is more than exclusive dating) then you just have to wait until the guy comes to you. He might need some time to process but its really not more complicated than that. And Yes you didnt clarify any of those ‘things’. They do matter in the early stages to sort of view where its going. To make the advice matter. To leave them out and then reply with s snobby i guess i didnt clarify this and that as if we are bunch of nutjobs who cant read cristal balls makes me say good luck to you, im out
BeccaSorry you took that so personally, I just thought saying that we had a good connection and are dating was enough. Guess not
CaetruEveryone processes grief differently. You can ask how he would like you to support him during this time and just let him know that you are there for him when he is ready. It sounds like he already said that he didn’t want to talk to anyone and you should respect that. It might not hurt to shoot him a message once a week to check in and let him know that you are thinking of him, but don’t expect a reply.
BeccaThanks. I think I’ll text him in a couple days asking how he is doing.
LaneBecca, you need to take 15 steps back here. IF what he said is true, his sister and family needs his support and he clearly told you that’s where his head and energy will be, not on you.
The best and only way to support a man in this position where you hardly know them is to just be there IF he reaches out. If not, you don’t text, send a smoke signal, call or do anything that will start irritating him. If this is a blow off, then you will be just be blocked. Don’t give him a reason (ammunition) to block you.
BTW, you are someone he barely knows and overly clingy tbh. His family, relatives, friends and even co-workers know him far better than you ever will so you are essentially at the bottom rung of his support system to put it into perspective for you.
Personally, if in this position, I would take this as a “blow off” and blow away by taking the “out of sight, out of mind” method.
JaneBecca, this is a tough situation. Its hard as without his sister becoming ill, you weren’t far enough into the relationship to know if it truly would work out, even despite all you’ve been through together and now suddenly everything is on hold and you don’t know where you stand. His reaction is completely normal, and it is very normal he would not be able to cope right now, and he would not be in the right head space for a new relationship, even if he was very much looking to enjoy a relationship with you before.
Just because his family problems are so terrible, it does not mean you aren’t allowed to be upset about how your relationship is going. You just need to understand its not personal and he does need space. So send the text to let him know you are thinking of him and will help if he needs it ,if you haven’t already sent it. Then you just have to wait to see if he reaches out in time. I know this is really hard, but it is important you give him his space to grieve or you’ll push him away. Maybe reach out again in a few weeks or when the sister passes if you don’t hear from him. But you must let him come to you when he is ready, if he is ever ready. I know its hard but don’t put your life on hold either.
-
AuthorPosts