Home › Forums › Dating and Sex Advice › I love my boyfriend but he's cheap! What should I do??
- This topic has 111 replies and was last updated 4 years, 6 months ago by ANM Staff.
-
AuthorPosts
-
August 25, 2016 at 2:52 am #559323Amy S
This is not a British thing at all btw. Im British and i met a load of very generous guys too. Im selective and dont entertain the cheapskates. One hit and they are out ! lol. Such a horrid trait imo. x
August 25, 2016 at 3:12 am #559326HannahYep in I’m the UK and this isn’t cultural. He’s just mean!
I’m all for equality but, if an man asks me out, he pays. I will offer, he will insist and I’ll thank him! I would pay sometimes too of course.
But this guy is just cheap. Even my friends pay for me sometimes so that’s the least I expect from a partner.
October 4, 2016 at 7:00 pm #568931RavenYes Mark, I’d like to see proof…
I’ve seen several 7.5″ dicks that really didn’t measure up…
October 16, 2016 at 10:05 pm #571386TiffanyI’m also with a guy that’s super stingy. We’re both 24 professional jobs with decent income. But the difference is I support my almost disabled mom (dad left for another woman two years ago) pay most of the bills at home, my bills and student loan. My bf lives at home rent free, spending most of his cash on performance parts for his car(S). I have some cash left over (not loads) after I take care of the bills yet I either pay majority of time or it’s 50/50. Nor did I get anything for my bday, after I told him what I wanted which was less than 30 dollars. I go to the gym, I’m not ugly and take care of myself. I don’t want him to pay my bills I just want to feel appreciated for the good woman I am.
October 16, 2016 at 11:01 pm #571400AfAs my husband says
They treat all of you like that because you LET THEM, plain and simple.
Don’t like it, let them know, give them space and time to step up, if they don’t do it, it’s done.
Don’t settle for less.
October 17, 2016 at 1:51 am #571408AmyTiffany you need to move on. Most guys out there still pay for dates. You can do so much better! And God bless you for taking care of your mom.
October 21, 2016 at 7:35 am #572318AnnieI have learned a lot reading the responses here. Thanks. I broke up ,2 weeks ago with a five year el cheapo. He made it a point not to spend even two dollars on me ever. He got angry constantly if I bought myself things.saying I should have given him the money instead. Once again in August no birthday gift. So I left him.
January 9, 2017 at 1:42 pm #591235Mark[Posts from ‘Mark’ deleted]
January 9, 2017 at 1:46 pm #591239HannahMark women are looking for husbands. Most women will take time some off of work to bring up your collective children. They want to find a man who can enable that. Is it wrong to want to find a man who can give you and your family a good life?
Equally, would you rather marry a loser woman with no job or prospects, or a woman who worked hard, earned money and looked after your home?
Once a woman is committed to a relationship, she’s normally very giving. She’ll cook for you, clean, do thoughful things for you and even organise your entire life if you want her to. But she has to know the man she’s investing in is worth investing in.
A man who wouldn’t even take me out for a drink or buy me a burger isn’t going to be a suitable partner for me. If he’s totally broke, he should be picky with who he chooses to buy the drink and the burger for.
January 9, 2017 at 2:01 pm #591244JackieMark, I dated a guy I was crazy about but he was broke due to paying child support, alimony, etc. It didn’t work. He felt embarrassed about not being able to afford much – I didn’t mind but he ended the relationship because of it. I was very sad but understood. I made more and I didn’t mind paying but we literally couldn’t do anything more than once a week unless I paid for it.
Guys have an innate need to “protect and provide” and if they can’t do it they feel like they are failing and unworthy no matter what a woman says.
January 9, 2017 at 3:35 pm #591271JackieMark, what is your age? I don’t think you understand how this male/female money thing works. I’m in my late 30s.
It wasn’t a communication issue. I told him repeatedly that I cared for him, money wasn’t going to matter but his ego and pride just couldn’t deal. I could see it in his face, over and over. And as a matter of fact we had a beautiful park nearby that we spend a lot of time in. Sometimes we’d walk and get a cup of coffee at the little coffee shop. I was happy with that. The deal breaker was we took a holiday together, I paid and he couldn’t afford to do anything unless I paid for it and that created a lot of stress for him.
HE couldn’t deal with not being able to do more for me. We aren’t kids, and he wasn’t OK with the situation. This wasn’t a matter of it being temporary due to job loss or something. This was how his life was going to be for another five years until he was done paying. He was sharing a house with a married couple friend of his.
I now make sure I date men who either make the same or more than me. It’s just easier that way. Anyone can get into a tight spot financially temporarily and I”m certainly not going to run over that; I just don’t date men who are financially strapped or low earners. Only tried it two times in my life because I genuinely cared for the guys. Thing is, you’ve gotta live in the real world and money is part of it. There has to be an equitable and comfortable place for a couple to get through.
And I’ve dated cheap once. Never again. They don’t change and they have underlying issues keeping them from trusting and being generous that I don’t see any point in dealing with. This guy she’s talking about – staying for free at someone’s house and you can’t even pick up the cost of a dinner out? Um, NO. I don’t care how many other good qualities he has, this is a deal breaker.
January 9, 2017 at 8:02 pm #591330NatMark you are right in principle except for “regardless of genders”. There is nothing regardless of genders. Are you the one to be pregnant for 9 months, then endure horrific delivery pain, then nurse your baby for a year and then look after the baby and the family, house while also working? One child, add another one. If your husband is not earning enough you are going to be miserable, your kids won’t have many options, entertainment will be pathetic, no travel, etc etc. Quality of life will suck.
When men date us, their spending money on us is a “signal” of what is there to come in the future from them. If they are cheap it means “bad quality of life” for everyone. If the guy earns little, it means the same thing. Money does not buy happiness but the lack of it can make you miserable.
Money is very important and in most families women spend several years with limited earning capacity, so they rely on men to support them and their kids. Why is it so hard to understand? If you don’t want to support a woman then no one is stopping you from getting pregnant yourself.
Life is much tougher for women overall. Physically, socially, emotionally. Women still get paid less than men for the same jobs. Harder to get a promotion for a woman. If you have kids, getting a new job is much harder as employers assume you’d be running out of the door sharp at 5 pm. Then when you grow older women have to endure hormonal changes all the while looking after their men, kids, grandkids, households and still work full time in many cases.
You are still very young so get yourself in the position to earn decent income. And if you meet a girl you think might be the one, pay for dates. Unless your girl is a spoiled brat she will make it up to you one way or another.
January 9, 2017 at 9:21 pm #591335PhillygirlApathetic, shiftless, stingy, and uninspired. That’s what we have here.
You have made all kinds of assertions and assumptions that are so off base.
While a couple in a healthy and mature relationship need to support and work together, your premise that it is not your job to aspire to something better and be a provider are absolutely pathetic.
I am a successful woman in a predominantly male dominated field. I worked my butt off to get where I am, and no I NEVER used my looks, body, or slept my way up the career ladder. I put in longer hours than many of my peers and worked harder to prove my merit.
Men like independent women? You seem to thing independent means being your mama. It means a woman who takes care of her OWN responsibilities, not YOURS. No self respecting man thinks the way you do. This is not about equality in a relationship, you seem to think you are entitled to have a woman take care of you. There is a big difference between a mutually supportive relationship and someone who doesn’t aspire to much, or anything at all, and thinks a woman with options will settle for that. All my exes appreaciated my independence, but they still wanted to take care of me. That is what a MAN does. A little boy or man-baby expects a woman to take his role. Were you raised by wolves, because I’d be ashamed if I was your mother.
Like attracts like. An inspired, motivated, successful woman usually wants a man who is just as motivated. It doesn’t mean he has to be wealthy, but he better be able and willing to be a provider.
The girls who would be with a guy without any ambition, who is also curmudgeonly and ungenerous is either:
-just looking for fun and “Mr Right Now” (not Mr. Right), or they likely lack healthy self esteem and an understanding of their own worth.I am generous with everyone I care about, and I volunteer my time and my resources for the things that matter to me. I would never be with a stingy, unmotivated guy who lacks ambition.
People who are ungenerous are usually stingy with everything, not just money. Their affection, praise, encouragement, effort and determination also tend to be scarce.
January 10, 2017 at 1:13 am #591364HannahWhat I was trying to say is what Nat was trying to say as well. Women look for signs the man is going to be husband material right from the start. (Or they should be if they have any sense!) Even at 22 I was thinking that way. If a man isn’t willing to pay to take me on a date, he’s not the man for me.
I want a man who’s generous. In time, emotionally and with money. If he has good prospects, I wouldn’t care if he was temporarily broke. But I would still want to see his generosity. Even if it was just a burger and a drink.
Equally a man could be a millionaire but, if he’s not generous, he’s not for me. Women are assessing this trait on the fist date. If you want to make a good impression, pay!I agree a man shouldn’t pay for every date though. After 3 dates, I think it’s fair to want the woman to pay for one date.
I actually have an issue around this at the moment. My husband earned much more than me for years. He paid a bigger proportion of the bills that whole time, although we’ve always gone 50-50 on big purchases such as our house. In the last 2 years, he’s started earning a lot less than me. It’s a real issue for him! I really want to go away together in March. I know he’s broke so I offered to pay. I reminded him of all the years he paid more than I did, but he’s not happy about it. He also hates to be the one stalling on making big purchases, even though he had no issue when it was me who couldn’t afford the do things. I guess it’s his male pride!
January 10, 2017 at 11:15 am #591448Helen@Raven, how do you raise kids “50/50?” Quite well, thank you. That is reality now. Parenting is a tag team event.
I think that there is a lot of confusion for men about this issue, particularly, millennials. From their perspective, they have grown up in a post-feminism world. Many of their peers, managers, etc. are women.
Some women are insulted by a man who doesn’t go “Dutch” and some are insulted by a man who doesn’t pick up the tab. I am a Gen-X’er, and if I am dating a man, and he and I are on equal financial footing (that I can tell), we both have kids, are divorced parents, etc. , we generally end up alternating over who picks up the bill, who pays for this or that, etc.
I don’t mind going Dutch, personally. I start to feel uncomfortable with a man who picks up the tab for everything, every time. I start to feel financially indebted to this individual, or our interaction is based on some financial relationship that I have with him.
I would just ask this gentleman why he insists upon splitting the tab each and every time, perhaps even tactfully describe why this can be socially awkward behavior in the US.
However, you’re most likely not going to make a dent in changing him at this point. This was probably ingrained in him by his parents, social situations, and past experience.I lived in the UK for several years, actually London. I did notice that men and women perceive “Americans” as being uber-wealthy and privileged across the board. With the exception of their upper class, most UK citizens live with much less money and possessions than most Americans.
January 10, 2017 at 11:36 am #591464RavenRaising kids is 100/100 …
You’re seriously telling me that in your relationship, you split the expense for your children right down the middle?January 10, 2017 at 11:36 am #591465Helen@Raven, you need to understand family law in your state if you do decide to marry at some point. If you go for the sugar daddy, you are going to find yourself facing a solid prenump. In most states, the days of alimony and child support, even if you had been staying at home with the kids, are limited to non-existent. Most men of character and quality want a women who is their equal, not a dependent. Or, if you are in “trophy wife” territory, you are still facing a rock solid prenup.
@Mark, I hear you that you want a woman who is your educational, financial, and ethically your equal. There is nothing wrong with you wanting this and getting it. Two equals makes for a more solid and lasting relationship. However, if you marry that woman with equal education, financial resources, and who is focused on her career…you will be looking for a solid, quality daycare when you have a child. Waiting around for June Cleaver to appear with a clean house, meals made, laundry folded, etc. while you stroll in after a hard day’s work… may not be a likely scenario. You both will probably be working, playing tag team with drop-offs and pick-ups at daycare, pediatrician appointments, staying home from work with a sick child, covering for daycare/school holidays, etc. Oh, and with your first child, you will be sick as a dog for a few years with all of the bugs that you are going to pick up from daycare. Even if you avoid daycare with a stay-at-home parent, you will then get sick one your child enters kindergarten/public or private school. It’s inevitable.
Oh, and then there’s the weekends. I think that more marriages with young children end because women get tired of earning half or more of the household income, but get stuck with all of the housework, cooking, laundry, etc. that consumes their weekend.
I am 20+ years your senior, mother of three, and of the women who I know who are stay-at-home moms, the reason why they stayed at home was that their earnings could not cover the cost of daycare. Or, they wound up having twins or triplets and the cost of daycare was crippling financially, even with a dual income family. Also, there are instances where the woman makes more than the man, and the father ends up staying at home. I know several stay-at-home dads.
January 10, 2017 at 11:49 am #591472Helen@Raven, yep. I was married for 13 years. Throughout my marriage I made, on average, 50-60% more than my spouse, carried the health insurance, and other benefits, and financially supported my stepson at about 50% when he resided with us (although I was under no legal obligation to do so). I actually went above 50% of the expenses most of the time, but we did pretty much split all expenses. It’s hard for a man to be with a woman who makes more than he does..this is a sensitive topic.
Now that we are divorced, we are literally, legally responsible for 50% of the expenses for our children. Actually, because I did make significantly more than my spouse in our last reported tax year, I was facing paying child support for our 3-year old. I fought it and ended up signing the house over to him (which we bought with my down payment and I predominately paid for maintenance and upkeep), in lieu of paying 15 years of child support. I didn’t fight too hard on the house, as this was the house that my kids grew up in. Oh, and I also wound up handing over 50% of all of my retirement accounts. That’s the law in my state.
As you can guess, I am not a proponent of marriage. It’s basically a legal status. And, if you go into it not knowing what can happen when you divorce, you could be in for a very ugly reality. I could just kick myself that I did not insist upon a prenup. I should have in retrospect.
The only silver lining is that I actually get a tax refund filing as a single person. LOL.
January 10, 2017 at 11:36 pm #591689NatThis post was OLD and yet got so much attention. The topic is HOT. lol
January 11, 2017 at 5:39 pm #591844GracieI had a Japanese boyfriend for 4 years and I’m from Mexico (talk about cultural diferences) At the beginning we were just hanging out as friends and then friends with benefits. There was not a written rule. The very first time, we probably split the check. The second time he paid for lunch and pay for coffee and it was like that. Once, very casually someone brought the topic and I told him in Mexico guy is expected to pay for the girl most of the time. He said it was like that in Japan and he though it was dumb. I took it and offer to pay certain things and where we went to a expensive place I offer to pay part of the bill or at least the tip. I went into a saving season for almost a year and he supported me (we were official by then) we would go out less or use grupons, we would check places within our range price, but he would always pay. He was still nice enough to not make me feel like a free loader and let me pay for coffee or ice cream, but never expected. I think, you can casually bring it up with a made up (or not made up story) and see what he has to say. In the story you can tell you think is fair for girl to pay some things, but not the whole or 50/50, specially if the guy makes more money. If it is a cultural thing you can tell, you are in a country where you are used to such and such.
BTW, I am currently in Mexico and dating a guy who pays almost everything, I feel a bit self conscious about it, but I can’t really afford the places we go. He seems to expect to pay for everything and I feel a bit ashamed to he paying for me, but seriously he wants to go for dinner almost every time we met and I could not afford to pay even once a week dinner in one of those places.
January 12, 2017 at 11:06 pm #592284SuzI can see how once you’re married there is both a legal (in the U.S.) and societal presumption that both parties kick in to the marital community in order to build a life together and there is an element of sharing the marital financial nut, as well as burdens, but if this guy squeaks when he walks at this stage in the game, I can’t see this getting anything but worse. If he is willing to be financially exploitive of your friends and family, and to some extent you despite the 50/50 paradigm y’all have going on, it’s only a matter of time before 50/50 turns into 60/40 or 70/30 or 80/20 or suddenly he only has enough for cab fare in his pocket at any given time.
The above said, if you feel that strongly about this man that you think you can see a future, then the onus is on you to sit down down with him and very clearly communicate how you feel, possibly even with a mediator or counselor. If he really loves you, he’ll see the error of his ways and try and be compromising, if he doesn’t, he’ll likely attempt to turn it around on you and make it out to be that you’re materialistic or a gold digger or whatever, at which point you show him the door. Generally speaking, anyone who is willing to exploit you financially and go so far as to exploit your friends and family in the same somewhat callous manner, will eventually graduate to exploiting you in other, more insidious ways.
January 17, 2017 at 7:03 am #593269JoanneI’ve actually just been broken up with by my English boyfriend because I complainedohim that I felt unloved and unappreciated because of his lack of generosity. Everything you said. I’m bearing a lot of expenses to see him. So much more, but an example is we went to lunch today with my mother. It was $30… and he offered to pay but quickly took money when cash was offered. It’s a little different because he doesn’t have a great job or make more money than I, but it’s not the dollar amounts that bug me so much as his willingness to put as much burden on me as he can get away with. It stinks.
May 9, 2017 at 10:22 am #625155AnnaHi , I do feel for you . I have the same problem . I live in London and all my exes were the same . My current boyfriend is the worst though. He doesn’t really make much money , we have the same jobs , but I work much harder so I make more than him and I also have to pay my rent and bill which he doesn’t because he lives with his parents but he will count every penny with spend , just to make sure he doesn’t pay a penny more than me . He bought me a coffee another day and I was so happy about it but then he mentioned it 5 times that he is super generous buying me that coffee :)
Idkmt think they can change I think it’s up to us if we can live with itMay 9, 2017 at 1:12 pm #625197LoveI had an ex like this and I think you’re right to be put off. It’s not just about money and being cheap, but as you say, generousity. I also have a theory that has proven true in pretty much all my relationships…..that how a person manages, saves and spends there money is an indication of how they manage emotions and resources in general. The 50/50 carried over into how we tried to manage a household, which was a nightmare. The fact is, if you intend to have a family with this type of person, be prepared of never feeling comfortable when bringing children into the equation…they don’t seem to understand that there are non-monetary value that partners bring into a household…and as a woman that has to deal with being off work, varying work prospect with child care, etc. this is a nightmare. Oh, and wait until someone gets sick…. This black and white 50/50 thinking with regards to finances is a real issue and ultimately I had to end things. Treating money as a transaction in a relationship leads to much bigger issues down the road. I hate to say it, but it doesn’t look good. I would have any honest chat with him…be brutally honest. Because if he doesn’t ‘get’ it now, he will not ‘get’ it 1, 5 or 10 years down the road.
May 9, 2017 at 3:49 pm #625225NatI agree with the others. Most men understand the value of “non-monetary” contribution a woman brings into a household and most men get ready to support and provide for the family. But some guys who are often socially ill adjusted use the feminist slogan of equality, which was originally meant to mean equal rights to have education, jobs, vote, etc., and eagerly and blindly take advantage of it for their personal benefit.
Ladies you can rejoice. These guys won’t be able to keep a good woman around. They will end up marrying “down”, someone who will be willing to put up with all the crap and cheapness. Because it is absolutely true what they say, cheap with money cheap with emotions. Life with those guys is not going to be fun. For this reason alone it is important to observe a man’s attitude towards chivalry and money. Being careful and not throw money around is one thing but being cheap is another.
I experienced the opposite last year. The guy I was dating for 6 months was overly generous. He’d show up on every date with something and I was getting annoyed, not pleased. Not surprisingly, he was generous with his time and emotions as well. He wanted to see me 4-5 times a week and called every day twice a day. I felt overwhelmed and suffocated. Go figure us women. lol
-
AuthorPosts
- The topic ‘I love my boyfriend but he's cheap! What should I do??’ is closed to new replies.