Home › Forums › Dating and Sex Advice › I'm not ready to be exclusive yet with a really great guy!
- This topic has 12 replies and was last updated 9 years, 4 months ago by JB.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Heather
I have a very happy dilemma, but it is a dilemma nonetheless. I am dating two very great guys. Both are very forthcoming about expressing their feelings for me and they’re wonderful men. The first, a doctor, I’ve been seeing for a little over two months. He has been saying and doing all the right things. I’ve never had to ask where the relationship is going (not that I would anyway) because every step of the way he has told me his feelings for me, has made it clear that he is looking to get married again and that’s where he would like to see this relationship heading, etc. The sex is absolutely amazing. Amazing. So what’s the problem? My problem is that it’s only been two months. I just ended a six year relationship and before that, I was married for ten years. So when I started dating again, I went out with probably 10-15 guys the first couple of months and narrowed it down to the two guys I’m seeing now (I did my own version of The Bachelorette.) The doctor wants us to be exclusive and here’s the bad part: I think he thinks we already are. He told me a couple of weeks ago he was taking down his online profile and wanted to date only me. He specifically told me he wasn’t going to ask that I do so too, but just wanted to let me know he only wanted to be with me. So I took down my online profile too because I wasn’t interested in dating anyone new because I was happy with the two I had. But we never discussed exclusivity directly but now I think he thinks taking down the online profiles meant that we are exclusive.
So this other guy, an attorney, is also very open with me about how much he likes me but he’s never mentioned what he’s looking for in a relationship (we’ve only gone on four dates so I have no expectation that he would talk about that this early and I’m not going to ask. If he wants me to know, he’ll let me know.) He is fun. He makes me laugh like no one else. He’s better looking than the doctor and a little bit younger (I’m 49, the attorney is 51, and the doctor is 55). The doctor is a little more conservative and uptight and the attorney’s personality is a little more like me – loose and easy-going. I also had sex with the attorney last weekend to compare the two (don’t judge me) and it wasn’t nearly as good as the doctor (who is amazing, did I say that already?) but it was the first time so I’ll cut him slack. Both men text me every morning, a couple of times throughout the day to say hello, and call me every night to chat about the day. They are both doing everything right to let me know their interest.
Anyway, if you’ve read this long my dilemma is that I’m not ready to be exclusive. How do I tell the doctor I’m not ready yet when I think he thinks we already are exclusive? I don’t want to date the attorney behind his back and I want to be honest, but since I think the doctor already thinks we are exclusive, its going to be an awkward conversation. Any advice on how to say it?
I don’t want to lose the doctor because he would be a perfect husband, but I really want to give the attorney a chance too because he’s so fun to be with. I wish I had another month or two to date both without freaking the doctor out because his last girlfriend of three and a half years left him for another man (who coincidentally shares the same first name as the attorney) and I don’t want to hurt him. I’m trying to keep my head in the present and not look too far down the road, but I’m 49 and I don’t have all the time in the world to find a life partner. I’ve worked very hard to keep a high level of hotness for an older woman, but I could wake up one morning and have turned into Crypt Keeper overnight so I feel a little age pressure too.
Sorry that was so long…..
DebbyThe choice seems so obvious to me…why does it not seem so for you?
Options2Do what the men do but a honest version. When either one backs off then you will know which one you will miss. If you are looking for a relationship with great love, follow your heart.
Do not worry about your age. It is just insecurity.
Be honest and don’t string anyone along. Good karma will always come back to you.
I would tell both that I can’t fully committed yet until i have clarity. Commitment will follow soon as decision is made. Be a great lady with inner beauty, you can always attract men for life regardless your age.
soniDebby said it. what’s there to even think about it?? I think u need to make up your mind soon or u may not only lose the doc but end up hurting him…
RuthI am was in this dilemma with 3 men. I’ve had sex with one of them. The one I slept with and one other are not ready for a relationship. They told me this and we are now good friends and I am not sleeping with any of them now. The one who is ready for a relationship has backed us off to just friends recently..probs cos he knew I had the other 2 on the back burner. I am bitterly regretting the other 2 now and wish I could turn the clock back cos I have fallen for bloke 3 and I have fallen hard. However it crossed my mind that having to chose between them all meant I probably shouldn’t be with any of them? I am keeping them all as friends, doing my own thing and seeing what happens in the future. Weirdly the one I slept with ( sex was mind blowing) is the one who makes the most effort with me and sees me the most and texts me at least 50 times a day. He’s away now and is still texting me all the time and sending me piccie of what he is doing. He met my children recently and gets on with them. He acts like he loves me but he doesn’t want a relationship. I was very sad a the time but accepted it. He’s not with anyone else 8 months on. I will never get men lol
KaremAsk the attorney to meet me, and I will resolve your problems in a second. hahah…
How many women would like to be lucky as you???!! Please don’t ruin what you have found so far. You can end alone without both!!
What is the site you are using? that you just found your own version of “The Bachelorette”Options2I think the issue is not either picking the apple or orange for now. It is finding the right fruit that you can enjoy and cherish over and over again.
Unless you just need to grab something to keep you satisfy for the time being.
MariaWow..what a dilemma indeed. If the attorney does not a relationship and he is not all that great in bed, then why are you hesitating to focus in the doctor? Attorneys are not to be trusted anyways, don’t you know? lol..like stock brokers.
And yes, I agree, you are in a dangerous age, so treat lightly and carefully. I’d go with a doctor and friendzone an attorney. He will understand, it is a business move. B I wouldn’t on’t tell either of them about exclusivity. Because how do you know what they have been doing?
JanetThink to yourself — who will you miss more if they stop contacting you — the doctor or the attorney? or alternatively, flip a coin –heads Doctor, tails Attorney ….deeeppp down which side of the coin do you want?
There’s nothing wrong with dating two guys at the same time –but you cant equally string both of them along, esp after having sex with both of them cuz then it’s going to create a big mess.
IMO, focus more of your time on the doctor — don’t discuss exclusivity, but just try to enjoy the time you two have with each other — can you see him as being someone you’ll spend time with in the future?
Spend a bit less time with the attorney, dont reply to his texts right away, but dont cut ties off with him yet. But perhaps, don’t have sex with him again.
If while you’re with the doctor you feel satisfied and completely happy, then maybe ditch the attorney. But if you find yourself missing the attorney and thinking about him, then maybe the doctor isn’t right for you and you should shift more of your attention to the attorney.
You said you’ve been with the doctor for 2months? I think that’s way too early to talk about commitments and exclusivity, so I dont think you should feel guilty about not knowing which one to pick.
ClaudiaI’m in the same position and I’m 64 years old…how about that! I have two wonderful guys and another guy that comes around sometimes. So, I’ve decided to just KEEP MY MOUTH SHUT to them until it becomes clear to me who I want, and it becomes clear who wants me for keeps, or not. Sorry, but I call this ‘dating’ and I don’t feel the need to reveal anything to either of them. The only thing I make clear is that I want a real relationship…a lasting relationship with one man. If they know that then it’s up to one of them to step up and if they don’t then I’m just dating anyway! It’s that simple in my mind.
HeatherI totally agree that two months is way too early to talk about exclusivity. The doctor assumed that when he brought up getting off the online dating site and I did, that it meant we were exclusive. To me, it meant that I didn’t want to date anyone new and that I was happy with my current rotation of two. I’m seeing the doctor tonight and have to bring this up with him gently. I’m not ready to be exclusive yet. If I were to make a list, all the check marks by his name would be filled. He’s even my same religion (Jewish). And while being stable and responsible is great, he’s not all that fun. The attorney is really fun and I have a blast with him. The attorney knows I’m dating other people and is working it hard to try to get me to choose him. He came by my house on Sunday and surprised me with champagne, flowers, and chocolates and helped me pack (I’m moving next week). I was in sweatpants and hadn’t showered yet that day and he told me how beautiful I looked. I feel in the long run, the attorney would be more accepting of who I am while the doctor would get annoyed with me because I don’t balance my checkbook or something boring like that. And even though the sex with the attorney was just okay the first time, it was the first time. I’ll have to give it a second try to make sure. ;)
So I think I will ask the doctor to slow it down a little bit, give me a little more space before being exclusive. I’ll still go out with the attorney and make sure he really likes me and its not a competition that he’s trying to win and then decide in the early fall with whom I want to be exclusive. The doctor will just have to accept it is too early for me. The doctor is everything on paper that I could possibly want in a man, but its the attorney who makes me really smile when I think about him.
After years of being incredibly needy and pushing men away, it is very refreshing to see how the advice on this website and Rori Raye and other similar relationship gurus really works. I have a very good problem and I’m lucky I have this problem. Once I started loving myself and putting myself first for a change, I’ve brought great guys into my life. It works, ladies!! Love yourself first. It took me several hard heartbreaks and pain to bring me to where I am today and I wish I knew what I know now at almost 50 when I was younger. It would have spared me a lot of grief. Don’t ever settle for less than you deserve.
Thank you everyone for your advice. Wish me luck!
HeatherClaudia, you go girl!!! <3
JBClaudia – You give me hope!! I’m 56 just entering the dating seen after 24 years married.
Heather – Thank you for sharing your journey with loving yourself first, it’s inspirational and good luck! Please let us know how it goes…living vicariously through you for now. LOL
-
AuthorPosts