Home › Forums › Dating and Sex Advice › should I remind him my birthday is coming or wait for him to forget
- This topic has 27 replies and was last updated 4 years, 11 months ago by Liz Lemon.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Chrissy
Hi… my bf and I have been dating for a year and a half. The first birthday I had since we’ve been together was when we were both away separately and I had to tell him after the fact that he missed it. I will be really upset if he forgets this year but he is kind of like that so I think chances are that he will. He doesn’t make a big deal of things like that.
I want to know if I should remind him ahead of time and tell him it’s important to me or wait and see if he remembers. I know if he doesn’t I will be pissed and it will not be good.
I have not let him know how important it is to me that my bday be recognized so that’s why in leaning towards giving him the heads up.JulesI think generally guys don’t view birthdays and holidays as important as women do.
If you know he doesn’t place an emphasis on birthdays and you know you’ll be upset if he forgets, go ahead and give him a heads up.
I don’t think I’d say, “its very important you do something special for my birthday” but maybe something a little more subtle like, “I’m excited! My birthday is in “X” weeks.”
If he’s a good boyfriend he’ll do something nice.
SusanYes tell him!!
My boyfriend forgot my birthday, was angry I didn’t tell him
Didn’t think I should have to after 4 years. The last 4 months have been hell for me
Remind him now for years of peace in the futurelisajust tell him you want to do something special together for your birthday. he will do something for you. or you can plan a special birthday date together.
don’t make yourself upset or mad. be happy and enjoy your birthday.
My bf and I will have our first valentine’s day this weekend. He is nerdy. doesn’t know how to plan. i am his first girlfriend. Then i took control. I planed something fun, and he told me he would be very happy to do that with me.
WIN WIN! :)
LekishaAgree with the ladies above!
Tell him, how excited you are :) Be resourceful :)
(Men needs some hints and some support when it comes to events and relationship activities!)
CFirst of all… We share the same name lol! (Not sure if that’s your nickname or what tho).
I’m a dating an unromantic guy who’s been super busy since November. My birthday was coming soon and I expected him to forget about it. So I just pop him a message, told him my birthday is next week babe! Are you gonna spend the day with me?
He apologized profusely and said he forgot about it and had a lot in his mind, which is true, I knew what he was going through with his work. I told him it’s okay and knew he would have forgotten since he’s so overwhelmed at that moment. He did take the time to make up and celebrate the day with me :)
So, just let him know!
Xx
ChrissyredcurleysueMen are different creatures.
Do not hold that against them.
Help him….he will be grateful.
AnaTell him! If you know you’ll be upset about anything, avoid that as much as you can and just be honest. Genuine honest is always better than a fight.
Chrissythank you all!! I will figure out some way to drop a hint… i really want him to remember but I think he will appreciate being reminded and I won’t be upset and disappointed.
Susan, I’m sorry your bf forgot your bday after four years. I would be really upset too. I bet he won’t forget next year..,LaneHi Crissy.
I’m sorry but Birthdays are big events for your PARENTS so to expect your BF to be all excited about the day you were born is ridiculous.
Men are different than us, if you want to date a woman then date one, but if you want to date a man then expect they won’t want to do all those womanly things or be emotional about stuff like this, sports yes, holidays no. Honestly, my ex husband and I of 20+ years only celebrated our anniversary because that was a “special day” for both of us, the rest don’t really matter in the grand scheme of things.
MeganThanks for this thread guys! It’s exactly what I needed as this weekend approaches and I am about to spend the day with a great guy who has no idea what he’s doing :) it reminds me to not get worked up about anything. Exactly what this forum is for.
GemmaIt was my birthday yesterday and my partner of 6 years forgot. It came up in conversation on Thursday when my friend came round to visit so he knew my birthday was just 3 days away then. I didn’t say anything yesterday to him and I was ok about it but today I’ve woken up upset and angry. This morning he was telling me how forgetful I am(don’t forget anything important) and well I had to say something. So I said to him he needs to have a think about what he’s forgotten about. so after some time he goes and checks the date and comes in and says happy birthday. I’m more angry at this point that he thought it was today, to which he denies saying he was saying it for yesterday. Really don’t feel like talking to him at all for some time. I would never forget his birthday. He has apologised and said he would be upset if I forgot his birthday but stil an apology doesn’t make up for it. If it was me I wouldn’t tell him, he should already know when your birthday is absolutely if he’s particularly forgetful Then every1 had calender alert son their phones these days so there’s no excuse in my opinion. Really hope he doesn’t forget your birthday. Hope u have a nice birthday xx
RachelI don’t agree with all this ‘poor men can’t be expected to remember’ rubbish! They are grown ups and while I agree they’re not that great at remembering they really should make the effort! I was married at 21, he never, not once in the following 16 years (or the 7 before that- yes we got together aged 14) forgot my birthday, if a 15 year old can do it I’m damn sure an adult can!! He did however forget our wedding anniversary a couple of times, but never birthdays. My fiance who I have been with for 2 years also never forgets, and was planning my 40th in June ready for September!
I wouldn’t make a big deal of it op, but i also wouldn’t make excuses for him. I would probably bring it up casually a few days before, and then he has no excuse.
NatI agree with Rachel. In my experience they don’t forget anything.
If you are angry then don’t pretend you are not. You have a good reason to be upset, it is your bd and it is important to you, so do tell him. If bds are not important to him, he will learn to appreciate that it is important to you.
If you don’t tell him and he forgets, then next year when it is HIS birthday, do NOT do anything for him, do not even say happy BD. Some people need to experience things to understand what it feels like.
LHmmm… second reason guys break up is because a woman gets her panties all wadded up over him not remembering a birthday! Doesn’t matter if he’s a perfect BF or husband.. they have to find something wrong with the guy.
RachelNo panties got wound up over mine as they never had to! Set some standards and don’t accept stupid excuses, that’s all I’m saying. If a guy can’t even remember your birthday, it shows how important you are. I’ve never had to remind a guy yet, but he’d get short shrift if he did forget!!! Mind you, I was married a long time, so maybe things have changed!
SamI’m woman and I forget birthdays!!! Lol… thank goodness for Facebook reminders. Ladies just chill. And by the way, most guys are not going to go into depression if you forget their birthday. They are more mature than that.
RachelI forget friends sometimes but never my ex husbands or my now fiance, I can’t see how that happens!!! Like I said above, my husband forgot a couple.of wedding anniversaries but that didn’t bother me , but he would have had no excuse about a birthday. Don’t ask me what the difference is as I can’t say, i just think it would become ingrained!
ShannonI think it depends on the guy, but I have read actual studies that men have difficulty remembering dates whereas women are better at this sort of thing. It has to do with right brain/left brain. Some men are better at it, as women here have testified to, but some are not.
I have always found it better to start reminding the guy a month in advance and tell him what I would like to do. To me, not reminding him to see if he remembers on his own is playing games.
NewbieI have no idea if my bf will forget my birthday or not, but he doesnt have to remember because in the week leading up to it there is always a reason to mention it. For example because youre inviting some friends etc. I forgot his btw. I could tell he was waiting for me to do something and it hit me suddenly. But anyway it serves no purpose to deliberately not mention it, so he can forget it and you can get mad. Thats silly
VanessaYou’re responding to a year old post!
How do you guys not see the dates??RachelIt was at the top so I responded! Sorry for not noticing!
cocomine missed my bday last year as well. He did not even realize he had missed it until he checked my facebook timeline 1 week after my bday. I told him how so much i felt sad, empty, and so very depressed, and he was sorry but im sure he will forget it again this year if i dont remind him. he is just forgetfull about all and it always makes him feel so bad as well. i just reminded him valentine’s day is coming up in 5 days and i cannot wait for the romantic dinner together lol. i think your bf is kind of like mine. reminding him your bday is coming us will save both you and him :)
AlgoDo you want to have a Nice birthday, or do you want to be right and hold it over his head?
I completely understand why you’d want to wait it out and see. But if you’re thinking about it that much ahead of time it’s sort of a test and a passive aggressive thing to do.
So I’d just very leisurely let it slip that you’re going to meet a friend of family member ‘for your birthday’ soon.
I know you want him to Remember but I think it’s better for everyone if you give him the reminder so you don’t have to face the possibility of a confrontatie.
No one likes friction, especially in a birthday.
JanetIf he’s your bf he’s your friend.
Why would you make a friend feel bad?
Tell him – help him make you happy!
Dates are not his thing – other things must be his thing, or you wouldn’t be with him? Yes?
Help him help you – tell him!
It’s my bday – …..ld love….lm excited etc
If he does nothing – bin him! Hahjaha
But give him a chance.
Clearly dates ate not his strong point – be kind and open x -
AuthorPosts